Menu updated Apr. 30, 2022 – items subject to change
Draft Beer & Cocktails
- Pint of Beer: $6
- Full Size Cocktail on Tap/Batch: $8 (frozen additional, as marked)
- TASTING FLIGHT – *Pick Any 4* – Each pour: $3/beer, $4/cocktail, $5/shots & frozen
- Flight w/ Pint: Flight of 4 beers + Pint of beer + Pint glass to take home: $24
| # | Beer Name | Style | ABV |
| 1 | Sandbar Sunday | American Wheat Ale | 4.8% |
| 2 | Islamorada Ale | Island Citrus Ale | 5.0% |
| 3 | No Tanlines | Citrus Wheat Blend | 4.9% |
| 4 | Channel Marker | Session IPA | 5.1% |
| 5 | No Wake Zone | Coconut Key Lime Ale | 5.0% |
| 18 | Queen Conch | Raspberry Summer Ale | 5.3% |
| 20 | Bud N’ Mary’s | Blueberry Summer Ale | 5.2% |
| 28 | Floridays | Hoppy Pale Ale | 5.6% |
| 31 | Snake Creek | Oatmeal Stout | 6.4% |
| 37 | Florida Gal | Strawberry Wheat Ale | 5.1% |
| 45 | Nested Reel | Sour Ale | 4.8% |
| 51 | Local Color | Key Lime Hibiscus Ale | 5.0% |
| 69 | Tropical Horizon** | IPA | 5.9% |
| 75 | Czech Your Bait | Czech Style Pilsner | 6.0% |
| 78 | Berry Smuggler | Whiskey Barrel Aged Sour with Blackberries | 4.8% |
| FR | Frozen Rotating Cocktail** | Frozen Cocktail ($5 taster/$11 12oz/$14 16oz) | 7% |
| FK | Frozen Key Lime Pie Cocktail** | Frozen Cocktail ($5 taster/$11 12oz/$14 16oz) | 6.6% |
| FN | Frozen Nonalcoholic Key Lime Pie** | Frozen Nonalcoholic ($4 taster/$7 12oz) | 0.0% |
| CP | Crooked Palm Pineapple | Vodka Soda on Tap | 5.0% |
| CC | Crooked Palm Cranberry | Canned Vodka Soda | 5.0% |
| CW | Crooked Palm Watermelon Key Lime | Canned Vodka Soda | 5.0% |
| CS | Crooked Palm Strawberry Cucumber | Canned Vodka Soda | 5.0% |
| BB | Berry Basil Bucha Cocktail | Gin with Kombucha | 4.0% |
| LL | Lavender Lemonade | Vodka Cocktail on Tap | 7.9% |
| PP | Pirate Punch | Rum Punch on Tap | 7.9% |
| VB | Very Berry (Lemonade) | Batch Vodka Cocktail | 7.9% |
| GP | Guava Pineapple Limeade | Vodka Cocktail on Tap | 7.9% |
Signature Craft Cocktails
| The Perfect Key Lime Pie Martini Islamorada Vodka or Gin, Key Lime Juice, Pineapple Juice, House-Made Cream of Coconut, Vanilla Syrup ($12) |
| Berry Jane CBD Cocktail House made berry lemonade with Islamorada Vodka, infused with CBD oil ($10) |
| Mermaid Magic Color-Changing Limeade Islamorada Hibiscus Gin infused with Butterfly Pea Flower and Elderflower Limeade ($10) |
| Frozen Key Lime Pie Cocktail and Frozen Rotating Cocktail Frozen drinks feature our Islamorada spirits mixed with Real Ingredients like Coconut Milk and Juices ($14 for full 16oz or $11 for 12oz) – add a floater! Spiced Rum ($4), Dark Barrel Aged Rum ($5.25) |
| Coming in Hot Islamorada Vodka, Jalapeno, Cilantro, Passionfruit Juice, Simple Syrup ($10) |
| Bold Fashioned Islamorada Dark Barrel-Aged Rum, Bitters, House-Made Coffee Liqueur, Orange Peel, Bing Cherry ($12) |
| Pineapple Kickin’ Mule Islamorada Vodka, Lime, Pineapple Juice, Jalapeno, Ginger Beer ($10) |
| Espresso Martini Islamorada Vodka, House Made Coffee Liqueur, Heavy Cream, Vanilla Syrup, and Espresso ($13) |
| Classic Mojito Islamorada Silver Rum, Lime, Mint, Simple Syrup, Soda ($10) |
| Ale Mary or Bloody Mary Bloody Mary with Islamorada Vodka, mix of spices, and a splash of Islamorada Ale for the house “Ale Mary” variation ($12.50) |
| ADD CBD oil to any beverage for $4.50 Reserve Rum Flight ($23) |
Spanky’s Kitchen – OPEN SUN & MON 12-4, TUE 3:30-7, WED 12-4 * SEE BTR below for Th-Sat food *
SHARABLES |
| Spanky’s Special Fish Dip Made from smoked wahoo, mahi mahi, and white fish, spiced with Senor Pelon’s Limanero Key Lime Orange Habanero Hot Sauce, served with crackers. 10.99 |
| Conch Fritters A Keys favorite. Bite sized (10) for the perfect ratio of crispy outside to tender inside. Served with side of tangy Caribbean aioli. 11.99 |
| Calamari Delicate calamari (“rings and legs”), flour-dusted with truffle seasoning. Served with Caribbean aioli. 12.99 |
| Coconut Shrimp Six jumbo, tender-crispy-fried, tail-on shrimp with a side of thai chili pepper jelly. 8.99 |
| Original Pretzel Rolls Two pretzel rolls with mustard. 6.99 Swap for beer cheese dip for 1.99 |
| Chips and Salsa Fresh corn tortilla chips served with housemade salsa blended from pineapple and fire roasted peppers. 5.99 |
BASKETS |
| Tuna Nachos – TEMPORARILY OUT OF STOCK DUE TO SHORTAGE Hot crispy chips piled with lightly seared sliced tuna, seaweed salad, honey orange eel sauce, and a creamy wasabi aioli. 14.99 |
| Pork or Chicken Nachos A pile of fresh tortilla chips with carnitas-style pork or fajita style chicken, beer cheese, our pineapple salsa, cabbage, asiago cheese, and green onions, drizzled with sour cream, with sides of hot sauce and pickled jalapeños. 12.99 |
| Naked Tender Basket Crispy chicken tenders with a side of fries, served with ketchup and ranch. 11.99 |
SANDWICHES |
| Fish Sandwich Islamorada Ale battered mahi, fried to fluffy flaky perfection, served on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, fried onion strings, asiago cheese, and thai chili pepper jelly. With a side of mango coleslaw and pickle. 14.99 Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99. Switch to gluten-free bun for 0.99. |
| Shrimp Sandwich Lightly battered crispy shrimp served served on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, house pineapple salsa, asiago cheese, and thai chili pepper jelly. With a side of mango coleslaw and pickle. 12.99 Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99. Switch to gluten-free bun for 0.99. |
| Eggplant Sandwich Breaded eggplant served on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, asiago cheese, and truffle mushroom aioli. With a side of mango coleslaw and pickle. 11.99 Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99. Switch to gluten-free bun for 0.99. |
| Pork or Chicken Sandwich Shredded pork or fajita style chicken served on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, fried onion strings, mango coleslaw, and tangy Caribbean aioli. With a side of mango coleslaw and pickle. 12.99 Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99. Switch to gluten-free bun for 0.99. |
SPECIALTY FRIES |
| Truffle Fries Double order of curly fries, tossed in truffle seasoning, asiago cheese, and cracked pepper. 9.99 |
| “Keys Poutine” Fries Our original creation of curly fries drizzled with rich and creamy lobster bisque. 11.99 |
| Curly Fries Side order sprinkled with Old Bay, served with ketchup. 4.99 or double order for 7.99 Add beer cheese dip for 1.99 |
TREATS |
| Peanut Butter N’ Jelly Bomb Sweet beer battered sandwich, served with strawberry preserves. V DF 5.99 |
| Fried Oreos Double stuffed Oreos (5), dipped and golden. 5.99 |
SNACKS |
| Gourmet Popcorn Ask for current flavors. 5.50 |
| Gourmet Mini Pretzels Hard pretzel cup – ask for flavors. 4.00 |
BTR Kitchen Food Truck – OPEN THU, FRI, SAT 11:30-6:30
STARTERS |
| Cuban Fusion Cuban sandwiches wrapped in eggrolls served with mustard aioli and a bag of plantain chips. 10.00 |
| Loaded Waffle Fries Waffle fries topped with melted cheese, bacon, and green onions, served with a side of sour cream. 10.00 |
| Tenders & Fries Fresh made chicken tenders served with choice of sauce and fries. 11.00 |
| 1 LB Bavarian Pretzel 1lb Bavarian soft pretzel with salt served with side of beer cheese and spicy mustard. 8.99 |
HAND CRAFTED BURGERS & FRIES 15.00 |
| Bacon Cheeseburger cheddar / bacon / red onion / lettuce / ketchup / mustard / mayo |
| Blue Burger Danish blue cheese / bacon / tomato / red onion / mayo / arugula |
| Brie Burger brie cheese / bacon / sweet pepper jelly |
| Goat Cheese Burger goat cheese / bacon / arugula / blackberry preserves |
| Guava Lane Burger swiss cheese / guava jam / bacon / mayo / mustard / crispy potato sticks |
| Horseradish Burger horseradish cheddar / horseradish sauce / bacon / lettuce |
| Orange Burger provolone / bacon / sweet & spicy orange marmalade slaw |
| Stout Burger aged Irish cheddar / stout beer sweet glazed coleslaw / bacon |
OTHER MEALS |
| Plain Hamburger or Cheeseburger & Fries 14.00 |
| Black Bean Burger black bean patty / cheddar / lettuce * choice of vegan cheese 14.00 |
| Classic Tender Sandwich & Fries fresh chicken tenders / bacon / provolone / mayo / lettuce / tomato 13.00 |
| Buffalo Ranch Tender Sandwich & Fries fresh chicken tenders / bacon / swiss / buffalo & ranch sauce / lettuce 13.00 |
| Side of Fries 4.00 — Extra Sauce .25 each — Extra Beer Cheese $1 each |
To Go Menu
| Packaged Beer Sandbar Sunday, Islamorada Ale, Channel Marker, No Wake Zone Coconut Key Lime Ale Rotating Flavors Subject to Availability: Go Fish American Lager, Floridays Hoppy Pale Ale, Queen Conch Raspberry Ale, Bud N’ Mary’s Blueberry Ale, Key Lime Hibiscus Ale, Nested Reel Sour Ale 6 pack or mixed 6 pack $10.99 Case or mixed case $39.99 |
| Draft Beer Growler Bottle 32oz $8 + Fill $9 32oz Fill for ** Beers $12 Growler Bottle 64oz $10 + Fill $18 64oz Fill for ** Beers $22 |
| Crooked Palm Canned Vodka Sodas 4 pack cans or mixed 4 pack $9.99 Pineapple, Cranberry, Strawberry Cucumber, Watermelon Key Lime |
| To Go Cocktail 32oz Bags $18 Lavender Lemonade (Vodka) Pirate Punch (Rum Punch) Very Berry Lemonade (Mixed Berry + Vodka) Guava Pineapple Limeade (Vodka) Other flavors available occasionally |
| Frozen Key Lime Pie Cocktail 16oz Cocktail to Go Bag $14 |