Menu

Menu updated Apr. 8, 2021

Draft Beer & Cocktails
  • Pint of Beer: $6
  • Full Size Cocktail on Tap/Batch: $8 (frozen additional, as marked)
  • TASTING FLIGHT – *Pick Any 4* – Each pour: $3/beer, $4/cocktail, $5/shots & frozen
  • Flight w/ Pint: Flight of 4 beers + Pint of beer + Pint glass to take home: $24
  • Actual list may vary slightly but we try to keep updates coming!
#Beer NameStyleABV
1Sandbar SundayAmerican Wheat Ale4.8%
2Islamorada AleIsland Citrus Ale5.0%
3No TanlinesCitrus Wheat Blend4.9%
4Channel MarkerSession IPA5.1%
5No Wake ZoneCoconut Key Lime Ale5.0%
28FloridaysHoppy Pale Ale5.6%
31Snake CreekOatmeal Stout5.3%
45Nested ReelSour Ale4.8%
51Local ColorKey Lime Hibiscus Ale5.0%
57A Pirate’s Passion**Passionfruit Wheat Ale5.4%
61Go FishAmerican Lager4.5%
63Angry CaptainFall/Brown IPA5.8%
67Barrel Aged Snake Creek**Woodford Reserve Aged Snake Creek5.3%
BBBerry Basil Bucha CocktailGin with Kombucha4.0%
FKFrozen Key Lime Pie**Frozen Cocktail ($5 taster/$11 12oz/$14 16oz)6.6%
CCCrooked Palm CranberryVodka Soda on Tap5.0%
CLCrooked Palm LimeVodka Soda on Tap5.0%
CPCrooked Palm PineappleVodka Soda on Tap5.0%
LLLavender LemonadeVodka Cocktail on Tap7.9%
PPPirate PunchRum Punch on Tap7.9%
VBVery Berry (Lemonade)Batch Vodka Cocktail7.9%
DRINKS MARKED ** not available for happy hour discounts.
Growler fills of 32oz for these beers have special pricing and 64oz fills are not available.
*** No happy hour pricing or growler fills of any size.
Signature Craft Cocktails
The Perfect Key Lime Pie Martini
Islamorada Vodka or Gin, Key Lime Juice, Pineapple Juice, House-Made Cream of Coconut, Vanilla Syrup ($12)
Berry Jane CBD Cocktail
House made berry lemonade with Islamorada Vodka, infused with CBD oil ($10)
Mermaid Magic Color-Changing Limeade
Islamorada Hibiscus Gin infused with Butterfly Pea Flower and Elderflower Limeade ($10)
Frozen Mexican Hot Cocoa or Frozen Key Lime Pie Cocktail
Frozen drinks feature our Islamorada spirits mixed with Coconut Milk and House Made “Secret Sauce” ($14 for full 16oz or $11 for 12oz) – add a floater! Spiced Rum ($4), Dark Barrel Aged Rum ($5.25) or one of our house seasonal shots ($5)
Coming in Hot
Islamorada Vodka, Jalapeno, Cilantro, Passionfruit Juice, Simple Syrup ($10)
Bold Fashioned
Islamorada Dark Barrel-Aged Rum, Bitters, House-Made Coffee Liqueur, Orange Peel, Bing Cherry ($12)
Pineapple Kickin’ Mule
Islamorada Vodka, Lime, Pineapple Juice, Jalapeno, Ginger Beer ($10)
Espresso Martini
Islamorada Vodka, House Made Coffee Liqueur, Heavy Cream, Vanilla Syrup, and Espresso ($13)
Classic Mojito
Islamorada Silver Rum, Lime, Mint, Simple Syrup, Soda ($10)
Ale Mary or Bloody Mary
Bloody Mary with Islamorada Vodka, mix of spices, and a splash of Islamorada Ale for the house “Ale Mary” variation ($12.50)
ADD CBD oil to any beverage for $4.50
PB Chocolate Shot ($5)
Blueberry Cobbler Shot ($5)
Zero Chill Celsius Energy Drink with Shot of Vodka ($10)
Reserve Rum Flight ($23)
Spanky’s Kitchen / MON, TUE, SAT AM, SUN PM

Spanky’s Special Fish Dip
Made from smoked wahoo, mahi mahi, and white fish, spiced with Senor Pelon’s Limanero Key Lime Orange Habanero Hot Sauce, served with crackers. 10.99

Tuna Nachos Docked & Loaded
Hot crispy chips piled with lightly seared sliced tuna, seaweed salad, honey orange eel sauce, and a creamy wasabi aioli. 14.99

Chips and Salsa
Housemade chunky black bean and corn medium salsa with fresh tortilla chips. 6.99

Curly Fries
Side order sprinkled with Old Bay, served with ketchup. 4.99 or double order for 7.99
Add beer cheese dip for 1.99

“Keys Poutine” Fries
Our original creation of curly fries drizzled with rich and creamy lobster bisque. 9.99

Creamy Crab and Artichoke Dip
Warm and creamy blend of crab and artichoke served with fresh made tortilla chips. 9.99

Mango-nificent Shrimp
Grilled shrimp topped with mango chunks, toasted coconut, and sweet n’ spicy mango drizzle. 9.99

Little Bit of Chicken Fried
Two crispy chicken tenders served with fries and your choice of honey mustard, ranch, or bbq sauce in addition to ketchup. 10.99

Original Pretzel Rolls
Two pretzel rolls with mustard. 6.99
Swap for beer cheese dip for 1.99

ENTREE STYLE ITEMS – the following items are served with a side of our Italian-style pasta salad. Swap for a side of fries for +2.99

Here Fishy Fish Taco
Lightly blackened mahi with slaw and a mild passionfruit cilantro-jalapeno sauce. Fashioned after our Coming in Hot cocktail. Two for 11.99, three for 16.49

Surf’s Up Tacos
Two tacos filled seared shrimp with a key lime butter aioli topped with slaw, mozzarella cheese, and our black bean and corn salsa. 11.99

Turf’s Up Tacos
Two tacos filled with Churrasco steak with a pink buffalo sauce topped with slaw, mozzarella cheese, and our black bean and corn salsa. 12.99

Beerly Legal Steak Sliders
Two marinated churrasco steak sliders topped with beer cheese and served on pretzel roll buns with Senor Pelon’s LargoRado BBQ sauce. 12.99

Wurst Thing on the Menu
Two pretzel bun sliders with a sliced grilled bratwurst that’s smothered in our delicious Islamorada beer cheese. 9.99

Avotacos
Two tacos of fried avocado topped with slaw, house ranch dip, and sweet n’ spicy mango drizzle with a side of black bean and corn salsa. 10.99

OFF THE HOOK CHuRRASCARIA MENU / WED, THU, FRI, SAT PM, SUN AM

Lamb Lollipops
3 pcs 14.99 | 5 pcs 19.99

Sandwiches
Pick your sauce: chimmichurri, off-the-heat, on-the-heat
Toppings: Swiss cheese, Grilled Onions $1
Meat: Churrasco (12.99), Picanha (11.99), Chorizo (10.99)

Tacos
Pick your sauce: chimmichurri, off-the-heat, on-the-heat
Churrasco 6.99, Picanha 5.99, Chorizo 4.99, Trio 16.99

Meats
Picanha – half pound 9.99 – pound 18.99
Churrasco – half pound 10.99 – pound 19.99
Costillas – half pound 7.99 – pound 15.99
Chorizo – half pound 6.99 – pound 14.99

Sides
Fries 4.99
Tostones 6.99

Kids Plates
Churrasco/Picanha with Fries 9.99
Chorizo with Fries 7.99
Sandwich (choice of meat) with Fries 9.99

To Go Menu
Packaged Beer
Sandbar Sunday, Islamorada Ale, Channel Marker, No Wake Zone Coconut Key Lime Ale, Key Lime Hibiscus Ale, Nested Reel Sour Ale (12 oz)
6 pack or mixed 6 pack $10.99
Case or mixed case $39.99
Draft Beer
To Go Cup (16oz) $6
Growler Bottle 32oz $8 + Fill $9
32oz Fill for ** Beers $12
Growler Bottle 64oz $10 + Fill $18
Crooked Palm Canned Vodka Sodas
4 pack cans or mixed 4 pack $9.99
Lavender Lemonade or Pirate Rum Punch
32oz Cocktail to Go Bag $18