Menu

Menu updated Sept 16, 2021 – items subject to change

Draft Beer & Cocktails
  • Pint of Beer: $6
  • Full Size Cocktail on Tap/Batch: $8 (frozen additional, as marked)
  • TASTING FLIGHT – *Pick Any 4* – Each pour: $3/beer, $4/cocktail, $5/shots & frozen
  • Flight w/ Pint: Flight of 4 beers + Pint of beer + Pint glass to take home: $24
#Beer NameStyleABV
1Sandbar SundayAmerican Wheat Ale4.8%
2Islamorada AleIsland Citrus Ale5.0%
3No TanlinesCitrus Wheat Blend4.9%
4Channel MarkerSession IPA5.1%
5No Wake ZoneCoconut Key Lime Ale5.0%
18Queen ConchRaspberry Ale5.0%
20Bud N’ Mary’sBlueberry Summer Ale5.2%
27Angler House**Amber Ale5.0%
28FloridaysHoppy Pale Ale5.6%
31Snake CreekOatmeal Stout5.3%
37Florida GalStrawberry Wheat Ale5.1%
51Local ColorKey Lime Hibiscus Ale5.0%
53OktoberfestGerman Style Lager5.0%
58Island Solitude**Pale Ale6.2%
61Go FishAmerican Lager4.8%
BBBerry Basil Bucha CocktailGin with Kombucha4.0%
FLFrozen Rotating Cocktail**Frozen Cocktail ($5 taster/$11 12oz/$14 16oz)7%
FKFrozen Key Lime Pie**Frozen Cocktail ($5 taster/$11 12oz/$14 16oz)6.6%
FBFrozen Berry SlusheeFrozen Nonalcoholic ($4 taster/$9 12oz)0.0%
CPCrooked Palm PineappleVodka Soda on Tap5.0%
LLLavender LemonadeVodka Cocktail on Tap7.9%
PPPirate PunchRum Punch on Tap7.9%
VBVery Berry (Lemonade)Batch Vodka Cocktail7.9%
PCPeach Cobbler ShotRum-based dessert shot13.3%
ICIrishmorada Cream ShotMade from our Spiced Rum13.3%
DRINKS MARKED ** not available for happy hour discounts or growler fills of any size.
Signature Craft Cocktails
The Perfect Key Lime Pie Martini
Islamorada Vodka or Gin, Key Lime Juice, Pineapple Juice, House-Made Cream of Coconut, Vanilla Syrup ($12)
Berry Jane CBD Cocktail
House made berry lemonade with Islamorada Vodka, infused with CBD oil ($10)
Mermaid Magic Color-Changing Limeade
Islamorada Hibiscus Gin infused with Butterfly Pea Flower and Elderflower Limeade ($10)
Frozen Key Lime Pie Cocktail and Frozen Rotating Cocktails
Frozen drinks feature our Islamorada spirits mixed with Coconut Milk, Real Ingredients, and Juices ($14 for full 16oz or $11 for 12oz) – add a floater! Spiced Rum ($4), Dark Barrel Aged Rum ($5.25) or one of our house seasonal shots ($5)
Coming in Hot
Islamorada Vodka, Jalapeno, Cilantro, Passionfruit Juice, Simple Syrup ($10)
Bold Fashioned
Islamorada Dark Barrel-Aged Rum, Bitters, House-Made Coffee Liqueur, Orange Peel, Bing Cherry ($12)
Pineapple Kickin’ Mule
Islamorada Vodka, Lime, Pineapple Juice, Jalapeno, Ginger Beer ($10)
Espresso Martini
Islamorada Vodka, House Made Coffee Liqueur, Heavy Cream, Vanilla Syrup, and Espresso ($13)
Classic Mojito
Islamorada Silver Rum, Lime, Mint, Simple Syrup, Soda ($10)
Ale Mary or Bloody Mary
Bloody Mary with Islamorada Vodka, mix of spices, and a splash of Islamorada Ale for the house “Ale Mary” variation ($12.50)
ADD CBD oil to any beverage for $4.50
Irishmorada Cream Shot ($5)
Peach Cobbler Shot ($5)
Reserve Rum Flight ($23)
Spanky’s Kitchen / MON 12:30-6, Fri 12:30-6, SAT & Sun 12:30-7

SEA SHARABLES

Spanky’s Special Fish Dip
Made from smoked wahoo, mahi mahi, and white fish, spiced with Senor Pelon’s Limanero Key Lime Orange Habanero Hot Sauce, served with crackers. 10.99
Conch Fritters
A Keys favorite. Bite sized (10) for the perfect ratio of crispy outside to tender inside. Served with side of tangy Caribbean aioli. 11.99
Calamari
Delicate calamari (“rings and legs”), flour-dusted with truffle seasoning. Served with Caribbean aioli. 12.99
Coconut Shrimp
Six jumbo, tender-crispy-fried, tail-on shrimp with a side of thai chili pepper jelly. 8.99
Tuna Nachos
Hot crispy chips piled with lightly seared sliced tuna, seaweed salad, honey orange eel sauce, and a creamy wasabi aioli. 14.99
Beer Battered Fish
Islamorada Ale battered mahi, fried to fluffy flaky perfection, served over greens and smothered in house onion strings, bacon, cilantro, lime, asiago cheese, and thai chili pepper jelly. 14.99
Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99
Beer Battered Shrimp
Lightly battered crispy shrimp served over greens, smothered in pineapple salsa, mango pieces, feta cheese, lime, cilantro, Old Bay, cayenne pepper, and kiwi lime drizzle. 14.99
Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99

SPECIALTY FRIES

Truffle Fries
Double order of curly fries, tossed in truffle seasoning, asiago cheese, and cracked pepper. 9.99
Loaded Steak Fries
Extra crispy steak fries covered in house beer cheese, sprinkled with bacon and green onions, with a side of ranch. 8.99
Swap bacon for pork for 2.99
“Keys Poutine” Fries
Our original creation of curly fries drizzled with rich and creamy lobster bisque. 9.99
Curly Fries
Side order sprinkled with Old Bay, served with ketchup. 4.99 or double order for 7.99
Add beer cheese dip for 1.99

SHORE SHARABLES

Original Pretzel Rolls
Two pretzel rolls with mustard. 6.99
Swap for beer cheese dip for 1.99
Pork Nachos
A pile of fresh tortilla chips with carnitas-style pork, beer cheese, our pineapple salsa, cabbage, asiago cheese, and green onions, drizzled with sour cream, with sides of hot sauce and pickled jalapeños. 12.99
Chips and Salsa
Fresh corn tortilla chips served with housemade salsa blended from pineapple and fire roasted peppers. 5.99
Chicken Tender Boat
Crispy tenders served over greens smothered in beer cheese, bacon, green onions, and ranch drizzle, with a side of buffalo sauce. 11.99
Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99
Naked Tender Basket
Plain tenders with a side of fries, served with ketchup and ranch. 11.99
Fried Avocado Boat
Tender fried avocado, served over greens and smothered in house onion strings, pineapple salsa, cabbage, asiago cheese, green onions, and sour cream, with sides of hot sauce and pickled jalapeños. 12.99
Add a side of curly fries with Old Bay for 1.99

GREEN THINGS

Tropical Salad
A bed of spring mix topped with fresh avocado, mango, thinly sliced purple onions, sunflower seeds, feta, and a kiwi lime drizzle, with mango vinaigrette on the side. 10.99
– Add fried fish or shrimp (4.99), seared tuna (5.99), grilled chicken (3.99), or crispy chicken tenders (3.99)

SNACKS & SWEETS

Fried Oreos
Double stuffed Oreos (5), dipped and golden. 5.99
Gourmet Popcorn
Ask for current flavors. 5.50
Gourmet Mini Pretzels
Hard pretzel cup – ask for flavors. 4.00
To Go Menu
Packaged Beer
Sandbar Sunday, Islamorada Ale, Channel Marker, No Wake Zone Coconut Key Lime Ale
Rotating Flavors Subject to Availability: Go Fish American Lager, Floridays Hoppy Pale Ale, Queen Conch Raspberry Ale, Bud N’ Mary’s Blueberry Ale, Key Lime Hibiscus Ale, Nested Reel Sour Ale
6 pack or mixed 6 pack $10.99
Case or mixed case $39.99
Draft Beer
No 64oz Fill for ** Beers – Select Beers Unavailable for Growler Fills
Growler Bottle 32oz $8 + Fill $9
32oz Fill for ** Beers $12
Growler Bottle 64oz $10 + Fill $18
Crooked Palm Canned Vodka Sodas
4 pack cans or mixed 4 pack $9.99
Pineapple, Cranberry, Lime, Strawberry Cucumber, Watermelon Key Lime
To Go Cocktail 32oz Bags $18
Lavender Lemonade (Vodka)
Pirate Punch (Rum Punch)
Very Berry Lemonade (Mixed Berry + Vodka)
Frozen Key Lime Pie Cocktail
16oz Cocktail to Go Bag $14